When Bonds Fall Short

The Shifting Roles of Bonds and Trend-Following in Portfolio Protection Before and After 2020

Publication artwork

Government bonds have traditionally played a defensive role in institutional portfolios, providing a valuable offset during equity losses in both the 2000s and the 2010s.

More recently, this protection has weakened, with Treasury returns turning negative during equity stress, while trend-following has provided a stronger diversification contribution. Against this backdrop, our analysis from 2000 to Q3 2026 examines the changing diversification roles of Treasuries and trend-following, with particular emphasis on periods of simultaneous equity and Treasury losses and the contrast before and after 2020.

We define equity stress as a monthly decline of more than 2% in the equity index and assess the performance of unscaled, fully funded U.S. Treasury futures relative to a representative trend-following benchmark during these periods. Both exposures delivered positive average monthly returns during equity stress in 2000 – 2009 (Treasuries: +1.4%; trend-following: +2.4%) but subsequently diverged. Treasuries outperformed in 2010 – 2019 (+1.7% vs. -0.6%), while trend-following led in 2020 – Q3 2026 (+1.7% vs. -1.2%). Trend-following also generated positive average returns when equities and bonds fell together – an environment that became substantially more frequent in the latest period. These differences translated into different portfolio outcomes.

With equity exposure held constant at 60%, the portfolio allocating 40% to trend-following delivered higher average returns than its Treasury counterpart during joint equity–Treasury loss months in 2020 – Q3 2026. It also outperformed a 60% equity / 40% cash benchmark, indicating a contribution beyond simply reducing equity exposure. Full-period risk-adjusted performance showed a similar reversal: the Treasury portfolio led on Sharpe ratio in 2010 – 2019 (1.31 versus 0.90), while the trend-following portfolio led in 2020 – Q3 2026 (0.95 versus 0.59). Both diversified portfolios exceeded the equity-only Sharpe ratio in 2000 – 2009. European and Japanese comparisons revealed similar shifts between the two later periods in equity-stress contributions and portfolio Sharpe rankings.

These findings describe a historical change in relative diversification effectiveness, not a structural advantage for either exposure. Both bonds and trend-following provided benefits, but their effectiveness varied across periods and market conditions. For institutional allocators, the evidence supports considering trend-following alongside fixed income to broaden the sources of portfolio protection and reduce reliance on government bonds alone.

Quantica Capital
Published
November 18, 2026
share